Lesson 06 · Use it on the next one
How to read a genetics headline
4 minute read
“Scientists find the gene for...” is almost always a compression of something more careful. These five questions recover the missing detail.
Which cell type?
A variant’s effect can exist in one cell type and nowhere else — the ETS2 story is exactly this. If the study does not name a cell type, its claim is probably about an average across tissue, which can hide the effect that matters.
How big is the effect?
An odds ratio of 1.03 across a population is a real statistical signal and a meaningless personal prediction. Ask for the effect size, not the p-value.
Coding or regulatory?
Coding variants change a protein and tend to have large effects. Regulatory variants change how much of a protein is made, and usually have small ones. Both are real; they license very different claims.
Has it been replicated?
A single cohort finding is a hypothesis with good PR. Look for independent replication, and for a mechanism — not just a correlation in one dataset.
Is it a preprint or peer-reviewed?
Preprints are how science moves fast now, and they are not wrong by default. But they have not been through review, and the wording of a press release rarely distinguishes the two. AlphaGenome 2’s own paper is a preprint; the original model’s paper is in Nature.
The one distinction worth keeping
Heritability is not determinism. A trait being 60% heritable means that, across a population, 60% of the variation between people is associated with genetic differences. It says nothing about how much of one person’s outcome is fixed, and nothing about whether anything can be changed.
And a boundary
A model that predicts molecular activity is not a diagnosis, a treatment plan, or a product recommendation. The moment a claim jumps from ’this variant changes expression in this cell type’ to ’therefore you should buy this’, the evidence has been left behind.
Check yourself
A study reports a variant with an odds ratio of 1.04 for a skin condition. What does that mean for one person?
“Heritability of 60%” means: